Legal presumption of work volume: how to claim fixed hours for structural overtime

·5 min read·Verzekeringsrecht
Legal presumption of work volume: how to claim fixed hours for structural overtime

Do you work as a call worker (e.g. in the hospitality industry) structurally more hours than stated in your contract✓ Then you can rely on the legal presumption of work volume (art. 7:610b BW). This e

Do you work as a call worker (e.g. in the hospitality industry) structurally more hours than stated in your contract✓ Then you can rely on the legal presumption of work volume (art. 7:610b BW). This ensures clarity about the number of hours you are entitled to - even in case of illness, schedule changes and wage continuation.

In this article, we explain when you can use the legal presumption, how to calculate the hours, what an employer can object to, and how this relates to the mandatory offer of fixed hours from the WAB (art. 7:628a BW).

What is the legal presumption of work volume?

After a minimum of three months of work, it is assumed that your contract hours are equivalent to the average number of hours worked in the past three months. This is a rebuttable assumption: the employer can try to prove that that period is not representative (e.g. due to a seasonal peak).

Why is this important?
The number of contract hours influences, among other things, wage continuation in case of illness, holiday days, holiday pay, pension accrual and schedule certainty.

When can you rely on the legal presumption?

  • There is uncertainty about your average work volume (typically with zero hours or min-max).

  • You work structurally more than agreed.

  • You are scheduled less while you previously worked more for a long time.

  • You are sick and there is a dispute about the average number of hours to be paid.

Attention: it must be a representative work period. If the 3-month period is not representative (a lot of replacement during holiday peak or less hours due to own illness/holiday), then another reference period may fit better (e.g. 12 months).

How do you calculate the work volume?

  1. Add your actual hours worked per month in the chosen reference period.

  2. Divide by the number of months (standard 3; sometimes 12 in case of peak/dip).

  3. The result is the monthly average (or converted weekly average) that you can claim as contract volume.

Example hospitality
You have worked an average of 25 hours per week on a zero-hour contract for the last 3 months. Then you can request to set your contract at 25 hours per week and claim arrears of pay if you are now scheduled less.

How can the employer rebut the presumption?

The employer must substantiate that the chosen period is not representative, for example because:

  • there was a case of temporary peak (summer, events);

  • you replaced colleagues (illness, leave, pregnancy);

  • your own hours in that period differed from the normal pattern.

If the rebuttal fails✓ Then your average is maintained as contract volume.

Relationship with the mandatory offer of fixed hours (WAB)

In addition to the legal presumption, the WAB rule applies: after 12 months of call agreement, the employer must within one month make a written offer for fixed hours at the level of the average over the preceding 12 months (art. 7:628a para 5 BW).

  • Do you refuse that offer or do you not respond in time✓ Then you can still appeal to the legal presumption.

  • If contracts follow each other with intervals ≤ 6 months, then those periods are added together.

Practical examples

  • Zero hours, structurally 24 hours: employee is suddenly scheduled for only 8 hours. With art. 7:610b BW he claims 24 hours + supplemental salary.

  • Summer season: 3 months of 30 hours per week due to terrace traffic; normally 16 hours. Employer demonstrates peak → 12-month reference period; result ± 18-20 hours.

  • Illness: employee drops out; average contract size determines wage payment and accumulation of leave.

Step-by-step plan to record your hours

  1. Collect evidence: schedules, pay slips, hours overviews.

  2. Calculate your average (3 months; or substantiate why 12 months is more representative).

  3. Send a written request to adjust contract size and fulfill arrears of pay.

  4. Does the employer not respond or does he refuse? Let us take legal action (negotiation or district court).

  5. Deadlines and limitation periods: don't wait too long; claims have limitation periods.

Frequently asked questions

Does the legal presumption also apply to min-max?
Yes. It concerns the actual average; the presumption works for all contract types with unclear or fluctuating hours.

Can I also use it when I am sick?
Just then it is relevant: the wage payment is in line with the average work volume.

What if the 3-month period is unfavorable to me?
Substantiate why 12 months is more representative (e.g. because you were ill during those 3 months or had vacation).

Can the employer reduce my hours as 'punishment'?
This could violate good employer-ship and your legal position from 7:610b BW. Let us take a look.

Help from Arslan Lawyers

We calculate your average, draw up the letter, assess representativeness, and litigate if necessary. For employees, we work free of charge wherever possible, as we recover our costs from the employer or legal aid‒or we make clear arrangements up front.

Frequently asked questions

When can I invoke the legal presumption of working hours?
After working for at least three months, you can invoke the legal presumption if you consistently work more hours than contractually agreed. This applies especially to zero-hour contracts or when there's uncertainty about your working hours.
How is my working time calculated under the legal presumption?
Your working hours are calculated as the average number of hours worked in the past three months. If this period isn't representative due to seasonal work or illness, another reference period like 12 months can be used.
What can my employer argue against the legal presumption of working hours?
Your employer can try to prove that the reference period wasn't representative, for example due to seasonal peaks, temporary replacement of sick colleagues, or other exceptional circumstances. The burden of proof lies with the employer.
Back to blog
Share this article

Need legal advice?

Schedule a free consultation with one of our specialists